Ordinance or law coverage: who pays for code upgrades

What ordinance or law coverage pays for

A building code sets rules for construction, such as wiring, plumbing, foundation height, and wind resistance. Codes change over time. A home built decades ago may not meet the code in force today.

After a covered loss, a local building department can require the homeowner to rebuild to the current code, not the older code the home met when it was built. That requirement can add cost that has nothing to do with the original damage.

Ordinance or law coverage pays the added cost of meeting that current code during the repair or rebuild. Without this coverage, the homeowner pays the code-driven costs out of pocket.

Code upgrades show up most often after wind damage, fire damage, and flood damage, because these losses tend to force a larger rebuild. A kitchen fire that destroys one wall may trigger a code review of the electrical panel for the whole house. A roof torn off by wind may trigger a current wind-rating requirement for the whole roof deck, not just the damaged section.

The coverage does not pay to upgrade a home that has no damage. It applies only when a covered loss happens first, and a code requirement attaches to the repair of that loss.

Why a standard policy excludes code costs

A standard homeowners policy insures against physical loss to the home. It does not insure against a change in the law.

Florida Statute 627.7011 shows this split directly. One part of the statute lets an insurer sell replacement cost coverage that excludes [1] "the costs necessary to meet applicable laws and ordinances regulating the construction, use, or repair of any property." The same statute requires insurers to also offer a version of replacement cost coverage that includes those code costs [1].

This is not unique to Florida. Insurers in many states sell a base replacement cost form, then sell ordinance or law coverage as a separate endorsement with its own premium and its own limit. The homeowner, not the state, decides whether to add it, unless state law sets a default the way Florida does.

The parts of ordinance or law coverage

Florida Statute 627.7011 describes three cost categories that the coverage can include.

• The increased cost to meet applicable laws and ordinances during repair or rebuild [1].
• The cost of tearing down the damaged property, including debris removal [1].
• Loss to the undamaged portion of the structure, when code requires it to be demolished along with the damaged portion [1].

The statute limits the loss to the undamaged portion. Under the included-cost version of the coverage, that part of the payout applies only to the damaged portion of the structure, unless total damage exceeds 50% of the replacement cost of the structure [1].

Each of the three parts pays for a different stage of the job. The demolition cost pays the contractor to remove what the code will not allow to stay. The increased construction cost pays for the materials and labor that meet the new code, above what it would have cost to rebuild to the old code. The undamaged-portion cost pays for the part of the building that had no loss, but that code requires to come down anyway.

A homeowner should ask a contractor to break out these three categories separately on the repair estimate. An estimate that mixes ordinary repair cost with code-driven cost is harder for an adjuster to evaluate against the correct coverage.

How the limit is set

Florida sets the limit as a percentage of the dwelling coverage limit, not a flat dollar figure. Florida Statute 627.7011 lets the homeowner choose a cap of 25% or 50% of the dwelling limit for the added code costs [1].

If a Florida homeowner does not make a written election, the statute deems the policy to include the 25% version [1]. The insurer must still offer the 50% option.

Other states set this coverage in their own way, and the amount can be a percentage of the dwelling limit or a fixed dollar amount. Check the current policy form and endorsements filed in your state, and read the limit on your own declarations page.

The percentage approach and the flat-dollar approach both have a practical limit. A percentage-based limit grows with the dwelling coverage, so a higher-value home gets a higher dollar amount for the same percentage. A flat-dollar base stays fixed unless the homeowner buys an added endorsement on top of it.

A homeowner should compare the dollar amount the limit produces, not just the percentage or the flat figure, against a realistic estimate of local code-upgrade cost for the home's age and construction type.

How to find this coverage on the declarations page

The declarations page lists every coverage on a policy and its dollar limit. Ordinance or law coverage, also called building code coverage or law and ordinance coverage, appears as a separate line from the main dwelling coverage.

Read the declarations page for the coverage name, the limit, and whether the limit is a flat dollar amount or a percentage of the dwelling limit. If the line is missing, the policy likely does not carry this coverage.

A homeowner who does not see the coverage, or is not sure what the limit means, should ask the insurer or agent directly before a loss happens.

The declarations page also lists the dwelling coverage limit. A homeowner needs that figure to check the math on a percentage-based ordinance or law limit, since the ordinance or law dollar amount moves whenever the dwelling limit changes at renewal.

How it works with replacement cost coverage

Replacement cost coverage pays to rebuild the home as it was, using similar materials and construction, without a deduction for age or wear. It does not add money for code upgrades that were not part of the original structure.

Ordinance or law coverage is a separate limit added on top of the replacement cost settlement. The replacement cost settlement pays to rebuild what was there. The ordinance or law payout pays the extra amount a current code adds to that rebuild.

Depreciation rules can still apply to the base claim before code costs are added. Read ACV vs replacement cost for how an insurer calculates the base payout that ordinance or law coverage builds on.

A home insured on an actual cash value basis, rather than replacement cost, settles the underlying damage at depreciated value first. Ordinance or law coverage still pays the added code cost on top of that settlement, but the homeowner should confirm with the insurer how the two coverages are sequenced on a specific claim.

Code costs after a flood: Increased Cost of Compliance

A standard homeowners policy does not cover flood damage. Flood coverage comes from a separate policy, most often through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).

The NFIP offers a benefit called Increased Cost of Compliance (ICC) for flood losses. FEMA states that ICC pays up to "$30,000" toward the costs to raise, relocate, demolish, or floodproof a non-residential structure to meet local floodplain rules [3].

FEMA ties ICC to substantial damage, defined as a case where "repairs will cost 50% or more of the building's pre-damage market value" [3]. A homeowner who receives the maximum flood claim payout cannot also collect the ICC benefit on the same loss [3].

ICC is adjusted as a separate claim from the main flood damage claim. A policyholder should ask the flood insurance adjuster and the local permitting office about ICC eligibility before starting repairs.

A homeowner in a flood zone can carry both a homeowners policy with ordinance or law coverage and a separate NFIP flood policy with ICC coverage. The two coverages respond to different causes of loss. A wind-driven loss runs through the homeowners policy. A flood loss runs through the flood policy, even when the same storm caused both.

How to document code requirements with the building department

An insurer pays for a code upgrade only when the upgrade is a real legal requirement, not a homeowner preference.

1. Contact the local building department that has jurisdiction over the property.
2. Ask for the written code requirement that applies to the repair, in the form of a permit condition, a red-tag notice, or a code citation.
3. Keep a copy of the permit application and any correction notice the department issues during inspection.
4. Give the insurer or adjuster a copy of each document, not a verbal summary.
5. Keep contractor estimates that separate the base repair cost from the added code-compliance cost, so the insurer can see what cost belongs under which coverage.

Questions