Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost in Homeowners Insurance

What actual cash value and replacement cost mean

Actual cash value (ACV) is the amount needed to repair or replace damaged property, minus depreciation for age and wear.^[1] Replacement cost value (RCV) is the amount needed to repair or replace damaged property, with no deduction for depreciation, using materials of like kind and quality.^[1]

An insurer sets ACV by first pricing the repair or replacement at today's cost. The insurer then subtracts an amount for depreciation. Depreciation reflects the item's age, its condition before the loss, and how long that type of item normally lasts.^[1]

RCV skips that subtraction. The North Carolina Department of Insurance defines replacement cost value as the amount of money needed to repair your home at today's prices of building supplies, or to replace your belongings at today's cost for a similar item.^[2]

Why the two methods pay different amounts

The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) illustrates the gap with a roof claim. A storm damages the full roof of a home insured for $200,000, with a $4,000 deductible. A new roof costs $10,000.^[3]

A replacement cost policy pays $6,000 no matter how old the roof is.^[3] An actual cash value policy pays less as the roof ages, because depreciation reduces the roof's value before the deductible is applied.^[3]

A policy with actual cash value coverage usually costs less to buy. It also pays less when you file a claim.^[3]

How an insurer is supposed to calculate actual cash value

Texas regulators state that the standard method for finding the actual cash value of a structure is replacement cost with a proper deduction for depreciation.^[5] You still have a right to the reasonable and necessary expense to repair or replace the damaged property, after that depreciation deduction.^[5]

Texas regulators also bar one common error. An insurer may not subtract a contractor's expected overhead and profit, or sales tax, on top of the depreciation deduction. TDI calls that an improper claim settlement practice on both actual cash value and replacement cost policies.^[5]

How replacement cost claims get paid in two steps

Many replacement cost policies do not pay the full RCV amount up front. The insurer pays the actual cash value first. After you complete the repair or replacement and send proof, such as a receipt or invoice, the insurer pays the difference between ACV and RCV. Insurers call that difference recoverable depreciation.

California law gives homeowners at least 12 months from the first actual cash value payment to finish the work and collect the rest of the replacement cost, and at least 36 months for a loss tied to a declared state of emergency.^[6] Other states set different deadlines, so check your policy and your state's rules.

An insurer that pays actual cash value first will not send the recoverable depreciation until you show that you repaired or replaced the property. Save the contractor's final invoice or store receipt, a copy of the contract or work order, and photos of the finished repair or the replacement item. Send these together with your claim number.

Recoverable depreciation has its own rules on tracking the holdback, meeting the deadline, and getting the second payment released. Read the recoverable depreciation guide for that full process.

Dwelling, personal property, and roof-only ACV rules

A homeowners policy often applies different valuation methods to different parts of a claim. Check your declarations page for the method that applies to your dwelling, to other structures, and to your personal property.

Florida law requires an insurer to pay at least the actual cash value of a covered dwelling loss up front, minus the deductible, then pay the remaining repair cost as the work is performed.^[4] If the loss is a total loss of the dwelling, Florida law requires the insurer to pay the full replacement cost, with no holdback for depreciation.^[4]

Florida law also lets an insurer limit a roof claim payment to the roof's actual cash value when a separate roof deductible applies, until the insurer gets reasonable proof that the policyholder paid that deductible.^[4] Some insurers also sell a roof-only ACV option as a separate endorsement, which can lower the premium and the roof payout. Read your declarations page and any roof endorsement schedule to confirm whether your roof is covered at ACV or at full replacement cost.

A personal property claim usually lists each damaged item on its own line. The insurer prices each item at its current replacement cost, then applies depreciation to that item based on its age, its condition before the loss, and how long that type of item normally lasts.^[1] A rug and a laptop wear out on different schedules, so the adjuster applies a separate depreciation factor to each category of property, not one flat percentage for the whole claim.^[1]

Extended and guaranteed replacement cost

Extended replacement cost coverage pays above your dwelling limit by a set percentage if rebuilding costs more than the limit after a covered loss. Guaranteed replacement cost coverage goes further. Colorado law names it as a distinct coverage that an insurer may offer in place of extended replacement cost or law and ordinance coverage.^[7]

Colorado requires an insurer to offer extended replacement cost coverage of at least 50 percent of the dwelling limit, and law and ordinance coverage of at least 20 percent of the dwelling limit, before issuing or renewing a replacement cost homeowners policy whose dwelling limit already matches the estimated replacement cost.^[7]

Building costs can rise fast after a widespread disaster, when many homeowners compete for the same contractors and materials at once. Extended or guaranteed replacement cost coverage protects you from a rebuild that costs more than your dwelling limit by the time the work is done.

How to find which method your policy uses

1. Open your declarations page. Look for the words "replacement cost" or "actual cash value" next to dwelling coverage (Coverage A), other structures (Coverage B), and personal property (Coverage C).
2. Check for an endorsement titled replacement cost on personal property, scheduled personal property, or roof actual cash value. An endorsement overrides the default method stated in the base policy form.
3. Read the loss settlement section of your policy form. It states the valuation method for each coverage and any conditions, such as insuring your home to a minimum percentage of its replacement cost.
4. Call your agent or insurer and ask directly which method applies to your roof, your dwelling, and your personal property, and ask for the answer in writing.
5. If you believe your policy was settled using the wrong method, contact your state insurance department consumer division.

If you file a claim, also ask your adjuster these questions in writing. Ask how much the insurer will pay now and how much it is holding back as recoverable depreciation. Ask what proof the insurer needs to release that holdback and what your deadline is to send it. Ask whether you have extended replacement cost, guaranteed replacement cost, or law and ordinance coverage, and what dollar or percentage limit applies to each one.

Example: comparing a kitchen fire claim under each method

Example. A kitchen fire destroys a refrigerator that cost $1,200 new eight years ago. The refrigerator's expected life is 12 years. The insurer prices a comparable new refrigerator today at $1,500.

Depreciation is 8 years used divided by 12 years of expected life, which is about 67 percent. The depreciated amount is $1,500 multiplied by 67 percent, which is $1,005.

• Actual cash value payout: $1,500 minus $1,005 depreciation equals $495, before the deductible.
• Replacement cost payout: $1,500, before the deductible, with no subtraction for depreciation.
• On a replacement cost policy that pays in two steps, the insurer pays $495 first, as the ACV amount, then pays the remaining $1,005 after you buy the new refrigerator and send the receipt.

The same math applies to the 10-year-old roof in the TDI table above.^[3] On an actual cash value policy, the roof's depreciated value of $7,000 minus the $4,000 deductible leaves a payout of $3,000, and the homeowner receives nothing more, because actual cash value coverage has no second payment. On a replacement cost policy, the same homeowner collects $6,000 for that roof, regardless of its age, which is the $10,000 replacement cost minus the $4,000 deductible.^[3]

Questions